1996: Dickens at the Holly
1997: Twas the Night Before Christmas Carol/A Christmas Carol
1998: Oh, Reilly! The Foreigner Annie Twas the Night Before Christmas Carol/A Christmas Carol
1999: To Kill A Mockingbird Oklahoma! The Sound of Music Steel Magnolias
2000: Guys and Dolls A Mousetrap Brigadoon Little Women
2001: Seven Brides for Seven Bothers Arsenic and Old Lace The Music Man FRANKENSTEIN Miracle on 34th Street
2002: Camelot Foxfire The Miracle Worker South Pacific Barefoot in the Park Meet Me in St Louis
2003: Nunsense Crazy For You Anne of Green Gables Carousel Little Shop of Horrors
2004: Red, Hot and Cole A Midsummer Night’s Dream Annie Get Your Gun Noises Off 1940s Radio Hour
2005: Man of LaMancha Crimes of the Heart Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat Cat on a Hot Tin Roof A Christmas Story
2006: Oklahoma! Lend Me a Tenor The Wizard of Oz Fiddler on the Roof It’s A Wonderful Life
2007: Anything Goes To Kill A Mockingbird My Fair Lady Chicago Annie
2008: The Boys Next Door How to Succeed In Business Without Really Trying Big River Into the Woods Steel Magnolias 1940s Radio Hour
2009: Father of the Bride Bye Bye Birdie Nunsense The Music Man Plaza Suite
2010: Bus Stop Damn Yankees Hello Dolly Wait Until Dark George Washington Slept Here Nuncrackers
2011: Arsenic and Old Lace Guys and Dolls The Importance of Being Ernest Play It Again Sam Pump Boys and Dinettes
2012: Rumors Radio Gals Miss Firecracker Contest Sylvia It’s A Wonderful Life
2013: Brigadoon Seven Brides for Seven Bothers A Mousetrap Mame
2014: Moon Over Buffalo Smoke on the Mountain SPAMALOT Macbeth White Christmas
2015: The Nerd Smoke on the Mountain Footloose Little Shop of Horrors Miracle on 34th Street
2016: Cabaret 9 to 5 Shrek the Musical You Can’t Take It With You Twas the Night Before A Christmas Carol
2017: The Putnam County Spelling Bee I Hate Hamlet 42nd Street Addams Family Musical Christmas Belles